Y11W34VC The grit question, fully
A psychologist named Angela Duckworth became famous for a specific idea: that passion and perseverance for long-term goals — what she called grit — predicted success better than talent. The idea resonated. Grit became a target in schools, a training focus in companies, a value parents tried to cultivate in children. Then the research got re-examined. This week's article examines what survives and what has been quietly walked back.
Core Vocabulary
perseverance
/ˌpɜːsɪˈvɪərəns/|per·se·ver·ance
noun
Continued effort and determination in the face of difficulty; the quality of not giving up despite obstacles.
Word Breakdown: Latin: perseverare = to persist; per- (through) + severus (strict/serious)
Word family: persevere (vb), persevering (adj)
Synonyms: persistence, tenacity, determination, steadfastness
Collocations: perseverance in the face of, show perseverance, require perseverance, perseverance pays off
Example: Duckworth's concept of grit combines passion with perseverance — not just persistence in the moment, but sustained commitment to long-term goals over years.
overlap
/ˈəʊvəlæp/|o·ver·lap
verb/noun
To share common features or cover part of the same ground; the area or quality shared between two things.
Word Breakdown: over- (beyond) + lap (Old English: lappa = edge/fold); to extend over and share territory
Word family: overlapping (adj)
Synonyms: coincide, share features, intersect, duplicate
Collocations: overlap with, substantial overlap, overlap in meaning, areas of overlap
Example: The article's central concern is that grit may overlap so heavily with conscientiousness — an existing Big Five trait — that it adds little explanatory power as a distinct concept.
conscientiousness
/ˌkɒnʃiˈenʃəsnəs/|con·sci·en·tious·ness
noun
The quality of being careful, thorough, and responsible; a disposition toward doing things correctly and completely.
Word Breakdown: Latin: conscientia = knowledge within oneself; conscientious = governed by conscience/careful
Word family: conscientious (adj), conscientiously (adv)
Synonyms: carefulness, diligence, thoroughness, responsibility
Collocations: high conscientiousness, trait of conscientiousness, conscientiousness predicts, conscientiousness measures
Example: Conscientiousness — one of the Big Five personality traits — encompasses carefulness, organisation, and reliability, and is one of the strongest personality predictors of academic and professional success.
contested
/kənˈtestɪd/|con·test·ed
adjective
Disputed or challenged; not universally accepted; subject to ongoing debate or disagreement.
Word Breakdown: Latin: contestari = to call to witness; con- (together) + testis (witness); contested = called into question
Word family: contest (vb), contestation (n)
Synonyms: disputed, debated, challenged, controversial
Collocations: contested concept, contested claims, contested evidence, remain contested
Example: Grit is a contested concept in psychology — the research base that supports it has faced serious methodological challenges that its proponents have not fully resolved.
overhyped
/ˌəʊvəˈhaɪpt/|o·ver·hyped
adjective
Promoted or publicised far beyond what the evidence or actual quality warrants.
Word Breakdown: over- (beyond) + hype (slang: exaggerated promotion); to be promoted beyond its actual merit
Word family: hype (n/vb), overhype (vb)
Synonyms: oversold, exaggerated, over-promoted, inflated
Collocations: overhyped concept, overhyped research, dismissed as overhyped, risk being overhyped
Example: The article argues that grit has been overhyped — taken up by schools and organisations as a transformative concept before the scientific evidence warranted such enthusiasm.
partial
/ˈpɑːʃl/|par·tial
adjective
Not complete or total; relating to only part of something.
Word Breakdown: Latin: partialis = of a part; pars = part
Word family: partially (adv), partiality (n)
Synonyms: incomplete, limited, fragmentary, selective
Collocations: partial evidence, partial picture, partial explanation, partial overlap
Example: The evidence for grit as a predictor of success is partial — it shows modest correlations in some studies but fails to replicate in others.
structural
/ˈstrʌktʃərəl/|struc·tur·al
adjective
Relating to the underlying arrangement or organisation of something; fundamental to how something is built or ordered.
Word Breakdown: Latin: structura = building, arrangement; struere = to build; -al = adjective suffix
Word family: structurally (adv), structure (n/vb)
Synonyms: fundamental, systemic, organisational, underlying
Collocations: structural barrier, structural inequality, structural problem, structural explanation
Example: The article notes that some critics of grit argue that focusing on individual perseverance ignores structural barriers — the social and economic conditions that affect who gets to succeed.
redirect
/ˌriːdəˈrekt/|re·di·rect
verb
To change the direction or focus of something; to send or channel something in a new direction.
Word Breakdown: re- (again/differently) + direct (Latin: dirigere = to guide); to guide in a different direction
Word family: redirection (n)
Synonyms: refocus, reorient, channel, steer
Collocations: redirect attention, redirect effort, redirect energy, redirect resources
Example: Instead of abandoning the concept, some researchers seek to redirect the grit discussion toward understanding when persistence helps and when it hinders.
Technical Terms
grit
/ɡrɪt/|grit
noun
Duckworth's concept: passion and perseverance for long-term goals
Synonyms: passion and perseverance, tenacious long-term effort, sustained determination
Collocations: demonstrate grit, high grit, grit predicts achievement
Example: Duckworth defined grit as the combination of passion and perseverance for long-term goals — distinguishing it from conscientiousness by its emphasis on consistency of interest, which she argued was as important as consistency of effort.
conscientiousness
/ˌkɒnʃiˈɛnʃəsnəs/|con·sci·en·tious·ness
noun
the Big Five personality trait of carefulness, organisation and responsibility
Synonyms: self-discipline, diligence, organised goal pursuit
Collocations: high conscientiousness, conscientiousness predicts, measure conscientiousness
Example: Conscientiousness — the Big Five trait most consistently associated with academic and occupational success — predicts outcomes across domains because it captures not enthusiasm but the reliable follow-through that converts intention into completed work.
meta-analytic critique
/ˌmɛtə ˌænəˈlɪtɪk krɪˈtiːk/|me·ta-an·a·lyt·ic cri·tique
noun phrase
analysis showing that results across many studies do not support strong claims
Synonyms: systematic review criticism, pooled-evidence challenge, meta-analysis-based rebuttal
Collocations: meta-analytic critique reveals, subject to meta-analytic critique, findings challenged by meta-analytic critique
Example: A meta-analytic critique aggregates results across many studies to test whether an effect holds at scale — and the meta-analytic critique of grit found that once conscientiousness was controlled for, grit's independent predictive contribution shrank substantially.
construct validity
/ˈkɒnstrʌkt vəˈlɪdɪti/|con·struct va·lid·i·ty
noun phrase
whether a measure actually captures the concept it claims to
Synonyms: theoretical validity, conceptual validity, measurement soundness
Collocations: establish construct validity, question the construct validity, construct validity of grit
Example: Construct validity asks whether a psychological measure actually captures what it claims to measure — and critics of the grit scale argued that its construct validity was questionable because the grit questionnaire appeared to measure conscientiousness under a different name.
effect size
/ɪˈfɛkt saɪz/|ef·fect size
noun phrase
the magnitude of a statistical relationship, beyond significance
Synonyms: magnitude of effect, Cohen's d, strength of association
Collocations: small effect size, effect size of the intervention, report the effect size
Example: An effect size translates statistical significance into practical meaning — a finding can be highly significant with a trivially small effect size when the sample is large enough, which is why reporting effect sizes alongside p-values has become standard in responsible psychological research.
Figurative Phrases
stick with it
To continue with a task, commitment, or long-term goal despite difficulties, boredom, or setbacks; to persist rather than abandoning when the going becomes hard.
Etymology/Type: idiom; no literal sticking
Synonyms: persist, continue despite difficulty, not give up
Example: The research on deliberate practice suggests that sticking with it matters less than sticking with the right kind of practice — sustained effort directed at comfortable rehearsal builds fluency without building expertise.
go the distance
To maintain effort and commitment all the way through to the completion of something demanding; to last the full duration rather than falling away before the end.
Etymology/Type: idiom from running
Synonyms: persist to completion, maintain effort over the full duration, last until the end
Example: Grit captures the tendency to go the distance on goals that take years rather than weeks — but critics noted that the same trait that sustains productive effort can also sustain commitment to a goal that should have been abandoned.
push through
To continue making progress despite physical or psychological resistance; to persist past the point at which stopping would feel easier or more natural.
Etymology/Type: idiom; figurative push
Synonyms: continue despite discomfort, persist beyond difficulty, keep going under resistance
Example: Knowing when to push through and when to recover is the fundamental skill of periodised training — the productive discomfort of progressive overload is different in kind from the warning signals of overtraining, but the distinction requires experience to read accurately.
weather the storm
To endure a period of difficulty, uncertainty, or adversity without abandoning one's purpose or position; to survive trouble by holding on rather than retreating from it.
Etymology/Type: idiom; no literal weather
Synonyms: endure a difficult period, survive hardship without giving up, persist through adversity
Example: Long-term achievement requires the capacity to weather the storm of setbacks without revising the underlying goal — which is the positive case for grit — but equally requires the wisdom to distinguish a storm from evidence that the goal itself is misaligned.
stay the course
To continue with an original plan or direction despite pressure to change or give up; to maintain commitment to a chosen path without being deflected by difficulty or doubt.
Etymology/Type: idiom from sailing
Synonyms: continue with the original plan, maintain direction despite pressure to change, persist without deviation
Example: Whether staying the course reflects grit or the sunk cost fallacy depends on the quality of the goal — the same behavioural pattern produces excellence when the goal is sound and entrapment when it is not.
follow through
To carry out an intention, plan, or commitment all the way to its conclusion; to complete what was begun rather than abandoning it at a point short of full completion.
Etymology/Type: idiom; not literal following
Synonyms: complete what was started, carry out an intention to its conclusion, not abandon partway
Example: Conscientiousness predicts life outcomes largely through its association with follow-through — the reliable completion of commitments that builds both skill and reputation over time in a way that talent alone does not.
Confusing Words
perseverance vs persistence
These words are often treated as synonyms, but they carry slightly different emphases that are worth preserving in careful writing.
- perseverance — continued effort in the face of difficulty or discouragement; maintaining effort despite obstacles. Perseverance implies that adversity is specifically being overcome — there is something working against the person, and they continue despite it. The word emphasises the struggle and the virtue required to sustain effort through it.
- persistence — the continued existence or maintenance of something over time; also, the continued application of effort without necessarily implying adversity. Persistence describes duration and continuation — a persistent effort is one that continues; a persistent problem is one that remains. The word does not specifically foreground the overcoming of obstacles.
If emphasising effort maintained specifically in the face of difficulty or discouragement, use perseverance. If describing continued effort or continued existence over time without specifically foregrounding adversity, use persistence.
conscientiousness vs consciousness
These near-homonyms are frequently confused in writing, but they describe entirely different psychological concepts.
- conscientiousness — the personality trait of being careful, thorough, and reliable; the Big Five dimension associated with self-discipline and organised goal pursuit. A conscientious student meets deadlines and checks their work. Conscientiousness is a trait dimension that predicts performance and life outcomes across decades.
- consciousness — the state of being aware and responsive to one's environment; the subjective experience of being awake and aware. Consciousness is one of the deepest problems in philosophy — what it means for there to be a subjective experience at all. It has nothing to do with diligence or self-discipline.
If referring to the personality trait of being diligent, careful, and reliable, use conscientiousness. If referring to the state of subjective awareness or the philosophical problem of experience, use consciousness.
overlap vs correlate
Both words describe a relationship between two things, but they operate at different levels of precision — one is spatial and conceptual, the other is statistical.
- overlap — to share common elements, features, or area; to have some portion in common. Grit and conscientiousness overlap — they share conceptual territory and practical behavioural correlates. Overlap is a non-quantitative description of shared content or area between two things.
- correlate — to have a statistical relationship; to vary together in a consistent pattern that can be measured. Grit correlates with conscientiousness at a measurable coefficient. Correlation is a specific quantitative claim about how changes in one variable are associated with changes in another.
If describing shared conceptual territory or common features between two things, use overlap. If making a specific claim about a measurable statistical relationship between two variables, use correlate.
- Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
- Opens in a new window.